At Astara , we help you find the vehicle you're looking for, as well as help you obtain the best financing and even benefit from our after-sales advice.
Among the many options considered when purchasing a car, today it is key to choose between automatic or manual transmission .
So much so that most manufacturers offer both options for all their models, in order to reach as many potential customers as possible.
Now, it is quite common that not all the differences between an automatic or manual car are well known, so we will identify them below and explain what advantages and disadvantages each option presents .
What is the difference between an automatic or manual car?
In fact, the theory of whether automatic or manual transmission is widespread and, in fact, evident in terms of the concept they propose.
The manual transmission is the traditional one that, as its name suggests, must be performed personally by the driver using the gearshift lever, with the aim of shifting up or down, as required by driving.
Today's automatic transmission allows the vehicle itself to adapt the revolutions to the driving needs, so the driver doesn't have to worry about this action.
Automatic or manual transmission: advantages and disadvantages
Driving between an automatic and manual car is initially very different, which has led to each option having its supporters and detractors.
But if we look at the practical side, we must consider the true advantages and disadvantages of each system. We analyze them below:
Manual transmission: advantages
- Vehicle cost: It is usually cheaper, at least as far as the transmission factor is concerned.
- Driving experience: Many drivers report a better "feel" when driving with a manual transmission. This feeling is even more pronounced when driving a car with sporty features.
Manual transmission: disadvantages
- More breakdowns: at least, a greater likelihood of suffering them, if we don't make optimal use of the gearbox, which will accelerate the rate of wear of its components.
- It requires more concentration: Many drivers view manual shifting as a constant, demanding requirement, which prevents them from enjoying driving more.
Automatic transmission: advantages
- Easier driving: It may not seem like it at first, but once you get used to driving without gears, it becomes clear how much easier it is.
- Greater efficiency: A car with an automatic transmission is designed to optimize driving and reduce polluting gas emissions as much as possible.
- Greater safety: since the driver can keep both hands on the wheel at all times.
Automatic transmission: disadvantages
- Brake demands: Engine braking is reduced, and without sequential shifting, the brakes suffer greater wear.
- Maintenance costs: The technological development of an automatic transmission comes with a greater number of more complex components. This requires more extensive maintenance and a higher cost of possible breakdowns than those experienced in a manual car, especially in the gearshift system.
What is better, an automatic or manual car?
The big question we get from many drivers in Astara who aren't sure what to choose is " what's better, an automatic or a manual car? "
The truth is, the answer depends entirely on the driver's preferences. Now that you know the pros and cons, you can get a better idea of what each option has to offer.
Things to consider when buying a car with a manual transmission:
- The vehicle's price will be cheaper than other options of the same model with automatic transmission.
- You'll have to pay constant attention to shifting gears, although this isn't a negative for everyone. In fact, some drivers say they only enjoy a full driving experience this way.
- Generally, maintenance costs will be lower , as will the risk of breakdowns, as long as you drive carefully and without demanding your driving habits. Furthermore, a manual car in the same conditions usually has the best fuel consumption. However, this depends greatly on the type of automatic transmission you're comparing it with.
Things to consider when buying a car with automatic transmission:
- If you've traditionally driven a car with a manual transmission, it takes a little getting used to the new way of driving at first.
- Over time, you'll find that driving an automatic car is much easier than driving a manual. Many drivers say they prefer this style of driving and, in fact, are no longer interested in cars with manual transmissions.
- You'll enjoy safer and more efficient driving, a plus if you want to do your part for sustainability.
- You'll likely have to pay higher vehicle maintenance costs , as the risk of breakdowns is higher, and if one occurs, repairs are also usually more expensive.
What lasts longer, an automatic or manual car?
Obviously, the durability of a vehicle cannot be attributed solely to its gearshift system.
Furthermore, it is important to note that, whether we are dealing with an automatic or manual car , it is best to ensure regular maintenance of the vehicle to reduce the risk of breakdowns and enjoy its useful life for as long as possible.
In any case, in terms of reliability, it should be noted that a car with a manual gearbox generally offers greater durability than one with an automatic transmission.
Of course, this also depends on the type of driving you do . The more we demand of each gear and the shifting system, the faster the associated parts will wear out.
In short, there is no better or worse option, but rather a number of factors to consider before deciding on one transmission or another.